Moths of Concern to Tree Health in High Park

Caterpillars of the introduced LDD/Spongy (Gypsy) Moths and native Fall Cankerworm Moths can be heavy defoliators of trees such as High Park's black oaks. Populations vary from year to year. The Forest Health Care unit of Toronto Forestry monitors these species and takes action to control them as considered appropriate. Oaks are the host plant for a variety of butterflies and moths. The caterpillars that feed on oaks also provide a valuable food source for migrant and breeding songbirds.

LDD Moth Monitoring

LDD Moth Egg Mass Surveys

In late summer, City staff conduct egg mass surveys in residential neighbourhoods, parks and natural areas, including High Park, to identify areas infested with LDD (European gypsy) moth. Survey areas are based on historically problematic areas and where the City of Toronto receives public calls annually during the caterpillar and moth stages. These surveys allow City staff to identify the infested areas and to predict LDD moth population levels for the following spring.

Defoliation Surveys

Defoliation surveys help to assess the level of feeding on tree leaves, in particular oak species, due to the LDD moth and to help guide where City staff may apply control measures. City staff will conduct defoliation surveys once feeding by caterpillars has stopped, as well as a few weeks after treatment for LDD Moth has occurred. Treated trees are inspected for signs of feeding and caterpillar abundance and are later re-inspected in the fall/winter for egg masses to evaluate impacts to the trees and to evaluate the success of the treatment.

Pheromone trapping

In areas across the City where the LDD moth may be starting to increase, the City deploys LDD moth traps. These traps are a population monitoring tool, not a control measure. The traps are baited with a pheromone that is effective in attracting male moths. Traps are hung in the lower canopy of trees in the summer, before the expected flight period in late July through August. Once the moths have died off for the season, the traps are collected and the number of moths counted. The data collected from these traps is used to establish further monitoring and treatment efforts.

Tree Wrapped for Parasitism Survey. Photo: Wendy Rothwell

Parasitism Survey

Parasitism is one of the greatest factors that contribute to the natural collapse of LDD moth populations. Since the LDD moth has natural enemies that affect the insect at each stage of development, City staff monitor the level of parasitism throughout its life cycle. City staff monitor the location, frequency and severity of parasitism in areas of the city to help predict LDD moth population levels the following spring. This is very important since City staff want to encourage natural factors like the Entomaphaga maimaiga fungus and NPV virus, which are naturally occurring in the LDD population and regulate the population when it gets too high.

News & Sightings

You might also be interested in...

Caterpillars of the introduced LDD/Spongy (Gypsy) Moths and native Fall Cankerworm Moths can be heavy defoliators of trees such as High Park’s black oaks. Populations vary from year to year. The Forest Health Care unit of Toronto Forestry monitors these species and takes action to control them as considered appropriate. Oaks are the host plant for a variety of butterflies and moths. The caterpillars that feed on oaks also provide a valuable food source for migrant and breeding songbirds.

LDD/Spongy (Gypsy) Moths

The LDD Moth (Lymantria dispar dispar), formerly referred to as the Gypsy Moth and now called the Spongy Moth, is a defoliating insect that can severely weaken or kill trees. This introduced insect is a major pest in North America. The caterpillar (larva stage) eats the leaves of trees, making them more susceptible to disease and damage from other sources.


Female gypsy moth on egg mass. Photo: Ken Sproule
Female LDD moth on egg mass. Photo: Ken Sproule
2012: The City’s 2012 survey of egg masses suggested that some areas of Toronto would see severe defoliation in 2013. There were over 300 trees identified with high numbers of egg masses (>15). These were almost exclusively located in the manicured areas.2013: Forestry conducted an LDD moth control program in 2013 in High Park. Since aerial spraying could harm other moths and butterflies, a variety of control techniques were used instead, including vacuum removal of egg masses, ground spraying with Btk (a subspecies of a naturally-occurring bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis), and where necessary injection with TreeAzin.2019: Aerial spraying of Btk was used in High Park for the first time in spring 2019. There were two applications to a narrow area bordering the main north-south roads and part of one east-west road. The broad use of Btk is a concern because other moths and butterflies can have a similar occurrence and lifecycle. The Natural Environment Committee met with Forestry in fall 2019 to discuss this change in procedure.2020: There was no severe defoliation of oaks in the season of 2020. An egg mass survey will be conducted this fall/winter to better understand the risk of an outbreak for the next season. A variety of control options may be considered beside pesticide spray, namely community involvement, treatment of selected trees, egg mass removal and other Integrated Pest Management practices, or alternatively let the LDD moth population complete the outbreak cycle.2021: Extensive defoliation occurred this spring, in High Park and many other parts of Toronto and southern Ontario. The amount of damage was unprecedented. Fortunately, the affected deciduous trees, including oaks, soon refoliated, helped along by a period of abundant rainfall.2022: All of High Park was sprayed three times with a new, more targeted product, BoVir. See the spring 2022 post for more details.Urban Forestry conducts regular monitoring of LDD moths (see below).For more updates regarding LDD moth management visit the Forestry website.

Fall Cankerworm Moths

Fall Cankerworm (Alsophila pometaria), a native insect, can be one of the most damaging defoliators of Toronto’s urban forest. Members of this family are often called inchworms, loopers or spanworms, since the caterpillars loop when they walk.Watch for the grey male moths in late fall when they fly in search of the flightless females waiting on tree trunks.Tree banding in High Park’s black oak savannahs by the City of Toronto and volunteers is an attempt to control the fall cankerworm population. Bands prevent female cankerworm moths from laying their eggs. Females are wingless. When they crawl up the tree they get trapped in the band’s sticky resin, as do the winged males who fly in looking for mates. This is intended to result in fewer cankerworms emerging in the spring, putting less stress on our black oaks.See Banding Demonstration videoUPDATE January 2018: Relatively high numbers of Fall Cankerworm were caught on banding traps throughout the city and throughout High Park in fall 2017. This indicates that there will be a noticeable presence of Fall Cankerworm next spring and defoliation as well. Oak trees that were banded last fall should have a noticeable reduction in defoliation for the upcoming spring compared to non-banded trees.Natural factors such as parasitism and mortality due to extreme cold may have an influence on populations of Fall Cankerworm. Other natural factors such as predators, nematodes, bacteria and viruses should also have an impact on Fall Cankerworm and help to collapse the population for upcoming years.
Fall Cankerworm Moth mating pair. Photo: Karen Yukich

LDD Moth Monitoring

LDD Moth Egg Mass Surveys

In late summer, City staff conduct egg mass surveys in residential neighbourhoods, parks and natural areas, including High Park, to identify areas infested with LDD (European gypsy) moth. Survey areas are based on historically problematic areas and where the City of Toronto receives public calls annually during the caterpillar and moth stages. These surveys allow City staff to identify the infested areas and to predict LDD moth population levels for the following spring.

Defoliation Surveys

Defoliation surveys help to assess the level of feeding on tree leaves, in particular oak species, due to the LDD moth and to help guide where City staff may apply control measures. City staff will conduct defoliation surveys once feeding by caterpillars has stopped, as well as a few weeks after treatment for LDD Moth has occurred. Treated trees are inspected for signs of feeding and caterpillar abundance and are later re-inspected in the fall/winter for egg masses to evaluate impacts to the trees and to evaluate the success of the treatment.

Pheromone trapping

In areas across the City where the LDD moth may be starting to increase, the City deploys LDD moth traps. These traps are a population monitoring tool, not a control measure. The traps are baited with a pheromone that is effective in attracting male moths. Traps are hung in the lower canopy of trees in the summer, before the expected flight period in late July through August. Once the moths have died off for the season, the traps are collected and the number of moths counted. The data collected from these traps is used to establish further monitoring and treatment efforts.

Tree Wrapped for Parasitism Survey. Photo: Wendy Rothwell

Parasitism Survey

Parasitism is one of the greatest factors that contribute to the natural collapse of LDD moth populations. Since the LDD moth has natural enemies that affect the insect at each stage of development, City staff monitor the level of parasitism throughout its life cycle. City staff monitor the location, frequency and severity of parasitism in areas of the city to help predict LDD moth population levels the following spring. This is very important since City staff want to encourage natural factors like the Entomaphaga maimaiga fungus and NPV virus, which are naturally occurring in the LDD population and regulate the population when it gets too high.

Report your LDD Moth caterpillar and moth sightings using this interactive reporting tool

City of Toronto LDD Moth (European Gypsy Moth) Reporting Tool. Source: toronto.ca

Visit the City’s LDD Moth webpage to report LDD caterpillar and moth sightings.

Ecology

History

Birds

Mammals

Herps

Fish

Insects

Trees + Shrubs

Wildflowers

Grasses

Wetland Plants

Invasive Plants

Research

Restoration

Volunteer

Maps